Compare

Graham Stephan and Joseph Carlson

Both records at the same windows, each against its own base rate; then every instrument both channels have called.

As of Nov 4, 2026, Callsight has checked both channels' calls at one year. Graham Stephan: 57.1% of the 84 calls that have a comparable base rate were correct, against a base rate of 47.2%. Joseph Carlson: 69.1% of the 68 calls that have a comparable base rate were correct, against a base rate of 61.2%. Every call links to the second it was said.

Choose two channels

The record at 1 year

Correct calls over correct plus incorrect, on the speaker's own calls, beside the base rate: how often the called move happened anyway in comparable past windows. The gap between the two, measured on the calls that have a base rate, is the edge, and it is the figure that can be read across markets.

Graham Stephan@grahamstephan · 5.1M subscribers · 862 videos read

Hit rate, 1 year

60.6%(104 calls)

63 correct · 41 incorrect (out of 104 checked calls)
After 3 years: 71.9% (89 calls) · on the 73 of 89 calls that have a base rate: 69.9% correct, base rate 51.9%

Above the base rate

+10.0pts

On the 84 of 104 calls with a comparable base rate: 57.1% correct, against a base rate of 47.2%.

Joseph Carlson@josephcarlsonshow · 511K subscribers · 190 videos read

Hit rate, 1 year

70.0%(70 calls)

49 correct · 21 incorrect (out of 70 checked calls)
After 3 years: 75.6% (41 calls) · on the 40 of 41 calls that have a base rate: 75.0% correct, base rate 67.5%

Above the base rate

+7.9pts

On the 68 of 70 calls with a comparable base rate: 69.1% correct, against a base rate of 61.2%.

Against its own base rate, on the calls that have one: Graham Stephan +10.0 pts on 84 of 104 calls, Joseph Carlson +7.9 pts on 68 of 70.

Most of Graham Stephan's own calls are about the economy; most of Joseph Carlson's are about stocks and funds. The two records below are measured largely on different markets.

Share correct at every window

30 days
50.5%97 callsbase rate 33.0% on 60 of them
40.8%71 callsbase rate 50.0% on 66 of them
90 days
51.9%106 callsbase rate 40.1% on 71 of them
55.6%72 callsbase rate 52.4% on 70 of them
180 days
58.8%102 callsbase rate 44.3% on 80 of them
60.8%74 callsbase rate 56.6% on 72 of them
1 year
60.6%104 callsbase rate 47.2% on 84 of them
70.0%70 callsbase rate 61.2% on 68 of them
3 years
71.9%89 callsbase rate 51.9% on 73 of them
75.6%41 callsbase rate 67.5% on 40 of them
5 years
72.7%55 callsbase rate 54.3% on 39 of them
50.0%4 callsbase rate 50.9% on 4 of them
Hit rateBase rate

Bar: the share correct. Mark: the base rate of that channel's own calls. A window a record is not old enough for shows the date its first result can exist.

By market, at 1 year

Economy
63.0%73 callsbase rate 38.8% on 55 of them
81.3%16 callsbase rate 32.0% on 14 of them
Stocks & funds
66.7%21 callsbase rate 68.0% on 21 of them
66.7%54 callsbase rate 68.7% on 54 of them
Crypto
30.0%10 callsbase rate 50.0% on 8 of them
no judged calls

Each share beside the base rate of its own market. A market neither channel has made its own calls in is left out; one with calls but no result yet says so.

Of each channel's calls that were correct after 30 days, how many were still correct after a year - with the opposite movement beside it.

Still correct after 1 year: Graham Stephan

Still correct after 1 year

9 of 16

Fewer than 20 calls have both results, so a count is shown and no percentage.
Over the same windows, 71.5% of 30-day moves in the same instruments were still in the same direction after 1 year (measured on 16 of 16 calls).
Correct after 30 days, still open at 1 year: 1

30 days → 1 year
30 days / 1 yearCorrect 1 yearIncorrect 1 year
Correct 30 days97
Incorrect 30 days47

Still correct after 1 year: Joseph Carlson

Still correct after 1 year

84.0%(25 calls)

21 of 25 calls that were correct after 30 days
Over the same windows, 75.4% of 30-day moves in the same instruments were still in the same direction after 1 year (measured on 25 of 25 calls).

30 days → 1 year
30 days / 1 yearCorrect 1 yearIncorrect 1 year
Correct 30 days214
Incorrect 30 days913

Where their calls agree and where they do not

3 instruments in common

Every instrument both channels have made their own calls on: each channel's latest call, the day it was made, and how it turned out where the window has closed. Two calls are set against each other only when they were made at most 365 days apart. Most recently spoken first.

Where their calls agree and where they do not
InstrumentGraham StephanJoseph CarlsonAgreement
SPYcalls: 46 and 7
will fallJun 25, 2026 · Incorrect after 90 days
will riseJun 30, 2023 · Correct after 1 year
Made more than 365 days apart: not compared
TSLAcalls: 8 and 1
will riseMay 23, 2022 · Not scored
will riseJun 23, 2025 · Correct after 1 year
Made more than 365 days apart: not compared
UBERcalls: 1 and 2No call on this one
will fallJun 23, 2025 · Correct after 1 year
Only one has a call to set against

Called in opposite directions within 45 days

The same instrument, one call up and one down, made at most 45 days apart - with what each one was worth at one year where that window has closed. The most recent disagreement on each instrument, newest first.

No calls in opposite directions made within 45 days of each other.

Market stance: Graham Stephan

The channel's own calls only. Up or down counts price calls and crash calls by the direction that was called.

Up 77 (71%)Down 28 (26%)No direction 3 (3%)

Predictions tracked

550

Not counted: 169 relayed from someone else, 155 own calls not scored

Judged calls

163

with a result at 30 days to a year

Share of vague calls

53%(506 calls)

(Of the channel's own calls, vague ones included, withheld ones left out)

Most called

Market stance: Joseph Carlson

The channel's own calls only. Up or down counts price calls and crash calls by the direction that was called.

Up 109 (87%)Down 16 (13%)

Predictions tracked

245

Not counted: 19 relayed from someone else, 97 own calls not scored

Judged calls

99

with a result at 30 days to a year

Share of vague calls

54%(366 calls)

(Of the channel's own calls, vague ones included, withheld ones left out)

Most called

Hit rates count each distinct call once, however often it was repeated, and leave out calls that could not be checked. Methodology